Skip to main content

New tax treatment of sale of unlisted shares brings more certainty, less litigation

As per Income Tax Law, Income earned from Sale of shares could be held as either Business Income or capital gains depending upon the facts of the case which had led to a lot of litigation over the years. The disputes persisted as assesses were finding it difficult to prove the intent of acquiring these shares.
In order to avoid disputes and take a consistent view in assessments of such income, CBDT has decided that income arising from transfer of unlisted shares would be considered under the head ‘Capital Gain’. It may be noted that a similar instruction had earlier been issued by CBDT regarding tax treatment of investment in listed shares but this instruction for unlisted companies is more beneficial as the requirement of period of holding has also been dispensed with.
It is however, clarified that this would not be necessarily applied in 3 situations where:
i. The genuineness of transactions in unlisted shares itself is questionable; or
ii. The transfer of unlisted shares is related to an issue pertaining to lifting of corporate veil; or
iii. The transfer of unlisted shares is made along with the control and management of underlying business and the Assessing Officer would take appropriate view in such situations.
How would this move benefit
This is certainly a welcome move for the taxpayer as capital gains are charged at a lesser rate than business income. By taking away the discretion with Assessing Officer, all disputes would be put to rest.
By putting restrictions on bogus transactions and also where the control and management of the underlying business is also taking place, CBDT has not allowed blanket application of this instruction and Assessing Officer has the liberty to decide on these three situations based on facts of the case.
This move would also benefit Angel Funds and Private Equity Funds and other investors as they would have certainty in the quantum of tax upon exit and many of those would also get benefit from favorable treaty jurisdictions like Mauritius or Singapore.
With so much frivolous litigation in tax matters, such steps from Income Tax authorities are surely welcome.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Reliance's JioMart is averaging half a million orders per day; WhatsApp driving growth

  JioMart , Reliance's online-to-offline commerce  platform that launched in May , has scaled up rapidly, riding on the pandemic-fuelled digital acceleration. The service, which went   live in 200 cities across India, is currently processing an average of  500,000 orders per day. " We can go even higher on peak days",  Jio Platforms CEO   Kiran Thomas  revealed at the Facebook for Fuel India 2020 event. He said, "JioMart is empowering millions of  kiranas  and small merchants through the simple and secure platform of WhatsApp, and linking them to Reliance Retail's pan-India supply chain. We expect to grow manifold in future, and are optimistic about enabling new cohorts of users and making it easier for them to shop for daily essentials."  "Customers are transacting seamlessly on JioMart and the  conversational nature of the service  enabled by WhatsApp has made people adapt to it intuitively," he added. Reliance also stated th...

Zomato, Swiggy score 1/10 on working conditions for their workers – ET Retail

Some of India's biggest startups have ranked near the bottom when it comes to  working conditions  for their gig  workers , according to a report released Wednesday. While  Swiggy ,  Zomato  and Uber India scored 1/10, Urban Company and Flipkart’s logistics arm EKart scored the highest 8/10 and 7/10, respectively, ‘ Fairwork India Ratings  2020: Labour Standards in the Platform Economy’  showed . The report assessed the companies on five principles: fair play, fair conditions, fair contracts, fair management, and fair representation. Deepinder Goyal, chief executive officer of Zomato Media Pvt. Ltd., acknowledged the ratings on Twitter. “Zomato ranked at the bottom of 2020 Fairwork India scores. We knew we had things to work on, but we didn’t know that there is so much room for improvement.” The company takes full responsibility and “will leave no stone unturned to perform better in the rankings next year,” he added. Zomato received a 4/10 in ...

Times Internet posts 24% revenue jump to Rs 1,625 Cr in FY20

  Times Internet has posted a 24% jump in its annual revenue in the financial year ending March, recording Rs 1,625 crore in revenue in FY20. In its annual report, the company  said the revenue growth has been adjusted for seasonality of cricket events. In FY19, it had posted revenues of $196 million. The company has registered a surge across its revenue streams i.e. advertising revenue, subscribers, transaction revenue and gross merchandise value (GMV) in the last fiscal year. While advertising revenue grew 22% with faster growth in music and video, overall subscribers to Times Prime grew 62%.  Times Internet’s annualized GMV in transacting businesses grew 68% with a 75% jump in net revenues, said the company in its annual report. Its subscription and transactional businesses include Times Prime, Gaana Plus, TOI+, ET Prime, and Gourmet Passport.  Times Prime also crossed 2 million subscribers last year. “We broadened our media strategy beyond news, and we focused on...